Syllogism Judge
A syllogism is a short argument with two premises and a conclusion. Logic asks one question about it: if the premises are true, must the conclusion be true? If the answer is yes, the argument is valid. If not, it is invalid.
In this game, you read a syllogism and judge it. Validity is about the form of the argument, not about whether the statements are true in real life. An argument can be valid with false premises, and it can be invalid even when the conclusion happens to be true. For example, 'all cats are animals' and 'all animals need water' lead to 'all cats need water'. The form works, whatever the words are.
That difference is hard at first, and the game trains it. After each answer, you see a short explanation of the argument's form and why it holds or fails. The game is free and needs no signup. Careful practice here helps you notice weak reasoning in daily arguments.
How to play
- Read the two premises.
- Ask whether the conclusion must follow.
- Choose valid or invalid.
- Read the explanation of the argument form.
Premise 1: All metals conduct electricity. Premise 2: Copper is a metal. Conclusion: Copper conducts electricity.
Premise 1: All roses are flowers. Premise 2: Some flowers fade quickly. Conclusion: Some roses fade quickly.
Premise 1: All doctors have studied biology. Premise 2: Maria has studied biology. Conclusion: Maria is a doctor.
Premise 1: All fish can fly. Premise 2: All salmon are fish. Conclusion: All salmon can fly.
Premise 1: Some students are athletes. Premise 2: Some athletes are musicians. Conclusion: Some students are musicians.
Premise 1: No reptiles have fur. Premise 2: All snakes are reptiles. Conclusion: No snake has fur.
Premise 1: No vegetarians eat beef. Premise 2: Some of my neighbors are vegetarians. Conclusion: Some of my neighbors do not eat beef.
Premise 1: No cats are birds. Premise 2: No birds are dogs. Conclusion: No cats are dogs.
Premise 1: All squares are rectangles. Premise 2: Some squares are red. Conclusion: Some rectangles are red.
Premise 1: All dogs are animals. Premise 2: No cats are dogs. Conclusion: No cats are animals.
Keep practising
Frequently asked questions
What does valid mean in logic?
An argument is valid when the conclusion must be true if the premises are true. Validity is about the structure, not about real-world facts.
Can a valid argument have a false conclusion?
Yes, if at least one premise is false. A valid argument with a false premise gives no reason to believe the conclusion.
What is the difference between valid and sound?
A sound argument is valid and also has true premises. This game focuses on validity.