Critical Thinkingexercises

Knights and Knaves

On the island of knights and knaves, knights always tell the truth and knaves always lie. You meet a few islanders, and each one makes a statement. From those statements alone, you must work out who is a knight and who is a knave.

These puzzles are a classic exercise in deduction. A good method is to assume one person is a knight, follow what that means for the others, and look for a contradiction. Some puzzles use statements about other people's roles, such as 'we are the same type'. Treat each statement as a claim that is true if the speaker is a knight and false if the speaker is a knave. If you find one, the assumption was wrong, and the opposite must hold.

In this game, you mark each character as a knight or a knave, then check your answer. Every puzzle has exactly one consistent solution. After you answer, the explanation walks through the reasoning step by step. The game is free and needs no signup.

How to play

  1. Read what each islander says.
  2. Assume a role for one person and test it.
  3. Mark every character as a knight or a knave.
  4. Check your answer and read the explanation.

Round 1 of 10

Knights always tell the truth. Knaves always lie.

  • Ava: "Bo is a knave."
  • Bo: "Ava and Cy are different kinds."
  • Cy: "Ava is a knight."
Ava
Bo
Cy

Frequently asked questions

What is a knight and what is a knave?

A knight always tells the truth. A knave always lies. You must decide who is which from what they say.

How do I solve these puzzles?

Assume one person's role and follow the consequences. If you reach a contradiction, the assumption was wrong. Try the other role.

Is there more than one answer?

No. Each puzzle has exactly one consistent solution.